The answer to this question most definitely involves inference because the reader is never told directly that Bruno's father does not like Maria. Father's treatment of Maria is simply a symptom of his beliefs about hired help. However, we can assume that the reason (at least for the appearance of dislike) has to do with what Bruno's father has been taught (and consequentially believes) about Jewish people: they are less than human. The best direct evidence is a quotation from Maria herself. When Maria admits that her thought process is unimportant, Bruno replies, “Of course it’s important ... you’re part of the family, aren’t you?” Maria then says, “I’m not sure whether your father would agree with that.” In regards to indirect evidence, we can point to Maria's continued fear of Father. This fear is found almost every time the reader sees Maria within the novel. Maria shows fear in revealing why they are moving. Maria shows fear that Bruno is inquisitive about the other men who work with Father. Maria shows fear in not revealing her displeasure in her new living arrangement. Maria shows fear that Bruno would show outright defiance to Father. Maria shows fear that Bruno would reprimand Gretel for her treatment of servants. Maria shows fear when she lies about Pavel's past. In each case, Maria's fear is connected with revealing her thoughts and feelings to Bruno.
No comments:
Post a Comment